If Volunteers Matter, Are We Investing Accordingly?

23 Nov 2026 | Articles

set of three stacked blocks with strategy, leadership and volunteers written on them

Rethinking Volunteer Management

Challenging conventional approaches to leading and supporting volunteers

There is a familiar pattern in organisations that rely on volunteers.

Everyone agrees that volunteers are important. Leaders talk about their contribution, celebrate their commitment and recognise the difference they make to the organisation and its communities.

Then the conversation turns to resources. “Can we afford another staff member?” “Do we really need that system?” “Couldn’t someone just coordinate the volunteers as part of their existing role?” “Perhaps we should recruit more volunteers first, and then we can look at investing.”

This is where leaders of volunteers face an important challenge: how do we make the case for investment in volunteering without simply asking the organisation to spend more money on volunteers?

Perhaps the better question is: if volunteers are important to achieving our organisational strategy, are we investing accordingly?

Start with the organisation, not the volunteer programme

The strongest business case for volunteering doesn't begin with the needs of volunteers. It begins with the organisation's priorities.

What is the organisation trying to achieve? Where does it want to increase its reach, improve services, strengthen community connections, build capability or respond to unmet need? Then ask: what role does volunteering play in making those things possible?

This changes the conversation.

Instead of saying, “We need more resources to improve volunteer engagement,” a leader of volunteers might say, “Our strategy identifies community reach as a priority, and volunteers currently enable us to reach X additional people. To expand that contribution safely and sustainably, we need to strengthen our volunteer infrastructure.”

The investment is no longer simply about supporting volunteers. It is about enabling organisational outcomes.

Make the contribution visible

Volunteer contribution is often hiding in plain sight.

We may know how many volunteers we have and how many hours they contribute, but those figures don't necessarily tell the organisational story.

What do those hours enable?
What services could not operate in the same way without volunteers?
What communities can the organisation reach because volunteers are involved?
What skills, relationships, local knowledge or lived experience do volunteers bring?
What would the organisation need to spend if those contributions were not available?

The answer is not to reduce volunteering to an hourly dollar value. Volunteers are not simply a cheaper form of labour. Rather, the organisation needs a fuller picture of the value created through volunteering — including relationships, community participation, skills, advocacy, connection, belonging and increased organisational capacity.

Make the invisible infrastructure visible

One of the challenges for leaders of volunteers is that much of their work is invisible when it is done well.

Recruitment appears straightforward.
Induction looks simple.
A volunteer role might be only a few lines on a webpage.

But effective volunteering requires systems, communication, supervision, training, relationship management, risk management, recognition, problem-solving and ongoing attention to the volunteer experience.

When that infrastructure is under-resourced, the consequences eventually become visible.

  • Volunteers leave.
  • Roles remain vacant.
  • Staff become frustrated.
  • Communication becomes inconsistent.
  • Opportunities are lost.
  • Risk increases.

The organisation may then conclude that “volunteers are becoming harder to recruit or retain”.

Sometimes the problem is not the volunteers. It is the infrastructure surrounding them.

Investment is also risk management

A volunteer strategy should therefore be part of the organisation's approach to quality and risk.

  • Are roles clear?
  • Are volunteers appropriately recruited and supported?
  • Are safeguarding and health and safety responsibilities understood?
  • Do volunteers know where to go when something goes wrong?
  • Are boundaries between paid and voluntary roles clear?
  • Are managers equipped to work effectively with volunteers?
  • Are volunteers included in organisational communication and decision-making where appropriate?

These aren't simply volunteer-management questions. They are organisational questions.

Give volunteer leadership a seat at the table

Another important part of the investment conversation is the position of the person leading volunteering.

If volunteers are strategically important, volunteer leadership cannot always sit at the margins of organisational decision-making. The role involves much more than matching people with tasks.

Leaders of volunteers understand community participation, volunteer experience, organisational culture, risk, inclusion, relationships and the changing expectations of volunteers.

They can see where organisational systems are helping or hindering participation.
They can also identify opportunities that others may not see. That perspective belongs in strategic conversations.

Demonstrate the return — without promising certainty

A good investment case doesn't need to claim that every dollar invested in volunteering will produce a precisely measurable return.

Instead, identify the outcomes the investment is intended to enable.

For example:
Investment: additional volunteer leadership capacity.
Intended outcomes: faster response to volunteer enquiries, better role development, stronger support for managers, improved volunteer experience and greater organisational capacity to engage volunteers.
Or:
Investment: improved volunteer management systems.
Intended outcomes: better communication, more consistent data, reduced administration and improved ability to understand participation and impact.

The important thing is to make the connection between investment → capability → outcome clear.

Ask what happens if we don't invest

Sometimes the most useful question is not, “What will this cost?” It is: “What will it cost us if we don't do it?”

  • What opportunities will remain unrealised?
  • What services might become harder to deliver?
  • What volunteer knowledge will be lost?
  • What risks will remain unmanaged?
  • What staff time will continue to be absorbed by inefficient systems?
  • What communities might we fail to reach?

Doing nothing is also a decision — and it has consequences.

The case for volunteering is ultimately a case for organisational capability

Leaders of volunteers don't need to convince decision-makers that volunteers are wonderful.

They need to help decision-makers understand what the organisation needs to invest in if it expects volunteering to contribute meaningfully to its goals.

That means moving the conversation from: “Volunteers need more support.”
to: “Our organisation relies on volunteering to achieve these outcomes, and this is what we need to invest to make that contribution sustainable.”

And perhaps the most useful question to put to any leadership team is simply:

If volunteers are important to achieving our strategy, are we investing accordingly?

The answer tells us a great deal about how seriously the organisation really values volunteering.


Volunteer Stories

One Mum's Story

A chronically sick child in a family usually means a lot of hard work - and not a lot of spare time. But a sick child in Dianne Smith’s family meant s...